Showing posts with label drama. Show all posts
Showing posts with label drama. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 22, 2014

Rhetorical Context in Cicero's Orations

"How important was the rhetorical Context of Cicero's orations: his listener's fear of Catiline's conspiracy and army?"


Cicero
     In my opinion, the rhetorical context of Cicero's orations was undeniably important in making his listeners afraid of Catiline's conspiracy and army!

     Rhetorical context is what made his speeches so fantastic!  I don't think that he would have gotten very far in his orations had he not used such good rhetoric.  Using outstanding rhetorical context was an amazing gift that he held in his possession, and he used it to stir up the emotions of many.  He had an advantage that no other man in history possessed.

     Thanks so much for reading, and please let me know what you think!

Thursday, December 12, 2013

The Libation Bearers (Orestes)

"What would have been Orestes' proper course of action had he been living today?  Why?"

     In the Libation Bearers, we see a man named Orestes attempting to avenge his father's death by killing his mother and her lover.  Orestes' mother, Clytemnestra, had killed his father to avenge the death of her daughter.  Orestes' father, Agamemnon, had killed the girl in hope of appeasing the gods.

     Well, if this was today, all these people would be in prison.  The proper course of action would be to go to the court system.  More likely, the court system would come to you if they knew of a murder that you were involved in.  They would not just stand around like a Dodo bird and do nothing.  (I mean no deceased Dodo birds offence by this statement.)

     His course of action would have been to report the murder of his father, testify in court, and see his mother go to prison.  Then, and only then, could he live a happy, regret-free, and worry-free life.

     Today, the proper course of action would be to not go into "serial killer mode".  If you did this, then you would be no better than the people/person that had committed the gruesome act that brought upon another's doom.

     Thanks for reading, and please let me know what you think!      

Tuesday, November 26, 2013

Tiberius Gracchus and the Struggle of the Orders

 "Why did Tiberius Gracchus attract so                much suspicion from the Roman Senate?" 

     To some, Tiberius Gracchus was a visionary.  To others, he was a poisonous spider that must be stomped on before it bites.  Needles to say, the people who looked down at him with a negative reaction would in the end, cause some disastrous consequences.  

     He was a politician that did things that simply weren't done.  This is why I believe that he received so much suspicion from the Roman Senate.  For instance, he ran for re-election as tribune which was not customary.  He also wanted to give back land to those who had fought by using tax revenues from one of the new kingdoms of Rome.  This was also not a customary practice.

     In the future, Tiberius is brutally killed over what we are told, was a misunderstanding.

     Later on, his idea of land commission ends up having some success.  This makes you wonder if perhaps the Roman Senate was more afraid of Tiberius' leaving of tradition, rather than his ideas.


"What specific changes occurred in Roman society as a result of the Struggle of the Orders?"

     First of all, let me give you some background information on what exactly the Struggle of the Orders was.

     The Struggle of the Orders was just that, a Struggle of the Orders.  These two orders, the Plebeians and the Patricians, were in a dispute over weather or not the Plebeians should have as much freedom as the Patricians did.

     In Roman society, if you were born a Plebeian, then you stayed a Plebeian no matter what.  Likewise, if you were born a Patrician, then you stayed a Patrician.  In this case, it did not matter how hard a Plebeian would try to gain as much freedom as a Patrician.  It was all about what class you were born into.

     After awhile, the Plebeians got sick and tired of being treated like second-class citizens, and rebelled.  They did this by leaving.  Since they greatly outnumbered the Patricians, this worked out rather well.

     Gradually, they started coming back.  Once they were back, they began to increase in freedom, but the Patricians did still have certain benefits that the Plebeians didn't.

     The Plebeians were getting the freedom that they had hoped for.  Intermarriage between the two classes was made legal, you couldn't be enslaved for debts you owed, and by 342 BC, one consul actually had to be a Plebeian!

     These were some of the changes that occurred in Roman Society as a result of the Struggle of the Orders.

     I hope that you have enjoyed this essay, and please let me know what you think!         

       

Tuesday, November 12, 2013

Medea (Thoughts)

"What does the fate of Medea and those who mistreat her and oppress her say about it's own time?"

     The play Medea is about a woman who has been left by her husband for a princess.  Obviously, she is upset about this. (Wouldn't you be too?)  She was in despair and she decided to commit a series of brutal murders in order to avenge the misfortune that her husband had brought upon her.
   
     In her doing this, we can see very clearly the affects that the Peloponessian War had caused.  (the play and the war were about the same time)
   
     This work of Greek drama has a mix of grief, anger, and love all wrapped up into one.  This being the case, I can see the same thing in war.
   
     War is typically brought on by grief (and or) anger just as the murders that Medea committed were brought on by these.
   
     In war we also see love.  Men leaving their friends and families can be tragic.  It tears the people affected apart.  It can be the making or unmaking of a person, and in Medea's case, it was her unmaking.
   
     It was tragic, just as the time of the Peloponessian War was tragic.  These are the things that I see reflected in the play Medea.

"Can we learn anything from Medea about the Greek's attitude towards foreigners and women?"

     Yes, I believe that we can.  In Medea we see both a mix of those that don't care what your gender is or about where you come from, and then again, we see those who do.  (Sounds a bit like society today don't you think?)
   
     We see some, (her husband, Jason for example) that can be sexist.  He seems to see Medea as no more than a play thing.  Something that he can leave and not reap the consequences of doing so.  And then we see others such as the king.  He seems less opposed to the opposite gender than did Jason.  We see this when his daughter is killed by Medea.  He is heart-broken by the loss of his dear daughter.  In this seen, we can tell that he really did care for his daughter.  It certainly didn't seem like he thought of her as no more than a play thing.
   
     Now I will do my best to answer the question concerning the view of foreigners.

     Medea was a foreigner and it appears that although she was respected by some, she was also mistreated by others.  (Again, I am using Jason as an example).  He left her for a woman of his own city.  Not that of another which Medea was.  And then again, we see the man who agreed to offer Medea safety in his land if she could get there.  It doesn't seem like he was very opposed to foreigners.

     Yes, I think that there where certain wide-held views of women and foreigners, but also that there were some who didn't have those views.  I believe that just like with anything in the world, it was a mixed lot.
     Thank you so much for reading, and please let me know what you think!